A bottlenose dolphin in the wild. (Photograph by Maddalena Bearzi)
By Maddalena Bearzi
I have spent much time in the company of wild dolphins over the last twenty-something years. I’ve built a career following their everyday movements and observing their behavior both from shore and from research boats. When I began my studies, I knew these creatures primarily as the objects of my research but, as the years passed, I came to recognize them as single individuals, not solely for their unique dorsal fin notches, but also for their cognitive abilities, personalities, and emotions.
Spending thousands of hours at sea, I began to know some of them by sight and, like my human friends, they became an integral part of my life. I learned of their needs, not only for space but also for companionship, and I witnessed their fluid, complex societies, which in many ways are quite similar to our own.
I have also witnessed first-hand the very different lives of these animals in aquaria and marine parks and I cannot help wondering about the reasons for keeping such magnificent creatures captive. In my line of work, I’ve heard all kinds of justifications for keeping dolphins confined, the most frequent being education, conservation, and research. (See: “First Person: How Far Will the Blackfish Effect Go?“)
Let’s consider whether any of these reasons are valid. And let’s do this keeping in mind that we are an allegedly intelligent and caring species with the ability to reflect and analyze what we currently know about dolphins and make sensible decisions based on these evaluations.
Keeping cetaceans (and personally I would stretch this to include other animals as well), in a restricted environment may have been more acceptable years ago, when we really didn’t know any better; when we didn’t have enough information about who these animals really are in the wild and what they need to live. But today, we know a lot more than we did back then.
So, what do we know about dolphins? Here, in a nutshell, are three important reasons why captivity and dolphins are incompatible.
1. Dolphins are large-brained, cognitive animals
If we consider ourselves as being at the pinnacle of intelligence, dolphins would come just after us, scoring even better than their great ape cousins. Looking at the Encephalization Quotient, which represents a measure of relative brain size and a rough estimate of the intelligence of an animal, dolphins possess a high EQ due to their unusually large brain-to-body- size ratios.
The last two decades have seen the proliferation of anatomical and morphological investigations on cetaceans. Neuroanatomical studies of their brains have shown that dolphins possess an intricate and developed neocortex as compared to other species, including humans, and a distinctive folding of the cerebral cortex, which in cetaceans is even more prominent than in primates.
Why is this important? Because, simply stated, these structures are both associated with complex information processing. Dolphins also have spindle-shaped neurons, or von Economo neurons, which are key for social cognition and have been linked in humans to an ability to “sense” what others are thinking.
There is no doubt that intelligence is difficult to define and when we look into the animal world, almost any animal may be considered “smart” depending on what definition of intelligence we decide to apply. I can make a great case for any of my dogs… But only in a few species like dolphins, great apes, and humans, do we find brain complexity, social complexity, and ecological complexity closely linked, at least for now… (See: “Schoolchildren and Musicians Boycott SeaWorld in ‘Blackfish’ Flap.”)
2. Dolphins live in complex societies in the open ocean
We have established that dolphins have large and complex brains, but what is all this brain capacity good for? This brain has allowed dolphins to develop complex and fluid societies in which they can flourish against the backdrop of a challenging, three-dimensional liquid environment.
Cetaceans such as the bottlenose dolphin (the most common species found in aquaria and marine parks today) have flexible and remarkable social and communication skills. They live in social networks characterized by highly differentiated relationships that often rely on precise memory of who owes whom a favor and who is a true friend. They engage in cooperative hunting and they partition resources such that prey is shared throughout the social group.
In some dolphin populations, males form coalitions in order to sexually coerce females or defeat other male coalitions. They care for each other; mothers and calves have long-term strong social bonds and a calf can spend up to two years next to its mother learning its place in the ocean. Dolphins play, bond, imitate, learn from each other and transfer information from generation to generation.
This ability to transfer learned behaviors to their progeny makes them cultural animals like us. And like us, they can recognize themselves as individuals and are self-aware, even if the extent of dolphin self-awareness still remains to be explored.
At sea, dolphins are always on the move, often traveling hundreds, sometimes thousands of miles. Their large brains likely help them to succeed in foraging on widely scattered and temporarily available resources. Dolphins, like some other animals, are essentially complex social mammals that need expansive space to live in. A tank can’t even begin to address these needs…
3. Dolphins have emotions (and personalities)
We like to think of dolphins as happy animals with an omnipresent smile frolicking in the sea. We tend to anthropomorphize them, projecting our own attributes on them. But what we think is the blissful face of a dolphin can obscure the animal’s true feeling, especially when we keep them confined. Let’s not forget that dolphins also die smiling!
Dolphins, like us, have a limbic system and are able to experience a broad spectrum of emotions including joy, grief, frustration, anger, and love. Put a dolphin in an MRI scanner and you will see a large brain structure that allows for complex emotions. Looking closer at a dolphin’s brain, once again, you will find those specialized von Economo neurons that in humans are linked to intuition and empathy.
But brains and neurons aside, it’s spending time in company of these animals in the wild that will really make a case for them as emotional beings with diverse personalities. Anyone who has witnessed the compassion of a dolphin mother in taking care of her calf, an individual helping a companion in distress, or a dolphin grieving for hours, even days for the death of a next of kin, can’t deny these animals have emotions.
Like intelligence, conscious emotion in these ocean-dwellers is difficult to understand, define, and measure. For comparison, just reflect upon how difficult it is to know what we ourselves are thinking or feeling at any given moment…
Now, let’s try something different. Let’s ignore all the scientific studies or what we currently know about dolphins. Let’s also disregard the three above-mentioned assertions why keeping these animals in captivity is fundamentally wrong, and let’s instead concentrate on debunking the favorite pro-captivity arguments: research, education, and conservation.
Read full story: National Geographic
Jason Chou liked this on Facebook.
Stacey Walker liked this on Facebook.
Rose Smith liked this on Facebook.
Fran DC liked this on Facebook.
Alison Holmes liked this on Facebook.
Stephanie Fritz liked this on Facebook.
Amber Starker liked this on Facebook.
RT @MarkCaney: Three Reasons Not to Keep Dolphins in a Tank #dolphin http://t.co/EIG9F525zt
RT @MarkCaney: Three Reasons Not to Keep Dolphins in a Tank #dolphin http://t.co/EIG9F525zt
Dee Dee Busko liked this on Facebook.
Debbie Aures Vanderkinter liked this on Facebook.
Shuichi Kobayashi liked this on Facebook.
Johanna Castro Miñano liked this on Facebook.
Milena Haler liked this on Facebook.
Uli Sharbinie liked this on Facebook.
Tjhie Lie Fong liked this on Facebook.
Mike Seares liked this on Facebook.
Jennifer Smith liked this on Facebook.
Andrea Sassano liked this on Facebook.
Crystal Raylene liked this on Facebook.
Snezana Rajic liked this on Facebook.
Teresa Kierans liked this on Facebook.
Anna Keane liked this on Facebook.
Don Murray liked this on Facebook.
Anu Susanna liked this on Facebook.
Reason 4. They might figure out how to operate the main armament and cause mayhem
John Gallienne liked this on Facebook.
Cheri Butler liked this on Facebook.
Kellie Kilgore Mosgrove liked this on Facebook.
Jenni Wojcik liked this on Facebook.
Trish Tuzzolino liked this on Facebook.
Murdo M Calder-macphee liked this on Facebook.
Lindsey Ferguson liked this on Facebook.
Ashley McGill liked this on Facebook.
Margaret Morton liked this on Facebook.
Rena Levy liked this on Facebook.
Sammy A Kowitz liked this on Facebook.
Cynthia Moody liked this on Facebook.
Rose Rogers liked this on Facebook.
Sharon Arnold liked this on Facebook.
Lisa Knowles liked this on Facebook.
Jamie DiEdwards liked this on Facebook.
Shamim Khan liked this on Facebook.
Danny Crenshaw liked this on Facebook.
Pamela Lee Shelton liked this on Facebook.
Stacey Cook liked this on Facebook.
Holiday Lammon liked this on Facebook.
Donna Joyce liked this on Facebook.
Linda Gilmore liked this on Facebook.
George Jennings liked this on Facebook.
Scotty Duncan liked this on Facebook.
Mark Peck liked this on Facebook.
Mary Lucy Georgina Harris liked this on Facebook.
Cindy Gordon liked this on Facebook.
Mac Fleming liked this on Facebook.
Kelly Virgill liked this on Facebook.
T.j. Johnson liked this on Facebook.
David Stewart liked this on Facebook.
Richard Ilderton liked this on Facebook.
Craig Dunford liked this on Facebook.
Barbara Trask Lovett liked this on Facebook.
Eric Ahumada liked this on Facebook.
Laura Viers Ratliff liked this on Facebook.
Erin Colleen liked this on Facebook.
Deborah Colleen Martin liked this on Facebook.
Betty Bobu liked this on Facebook.
James Larson liked this on Facebook.
Shannon Wise River Murray liked this on Facebook.
Mary Elizabeth Thomas liked this on Facebook.
Rising Sun liked this on Facebook.
Angela Gregorio liked this on Facebook.
Jay Wilasinee liked this on Facebook.
Courtney Leah Holding liked this on Facebook.
Brooke Dennis liked this on Facebook.
Ashley Waters liked this on Facebook.
Carley MumtoZack Matthews liked this on Facebook.
Aimee Duhig liked this on Facebook.
Claire Anderson liked this on Facebook.
Sam Brown liked this on Facebook.
Chris Allen liked this on Facebook.
Tracey Oliver liked this on Facebook.
Devona Montoya-Waddell liked this on Facebook.
Casey Marie Barrett liked this on Facebook.
Kerrie Proud-wells liked this on Facebook.
Zulma Duran-Cely liked this on Facebook.
Sacha Kathlene Blackmore liked this on Facebook.
Vaida Asta liked this on Facebook.
Jacki Harding liked this on Facebook.
Louise Trower liked this on Facebook.
Sasha Tripp liked this on Facebook.
Joanie Hann liked this on Facebook.
Peter Higgins liked this on Facebook.
Sylvia Walker Lenderyou liked this on Facebook.
Louise Hedges liked this on Facebook.
Fungie Forever Photo’s of the Dingle Dolphin liked this on Facebook.
RT @MarkCaney: Three Reasons Not to Keep Dolphins in a Tank #dolphin http://t.co/EIG9F525zt
Jesse Rudnik liked this on Facebook.
Tiffany Robinson liked this on Facebook.
Janet Fox liked this on Facebook.
Karen Page liked this on Facebook.